What "Show, Don't Tell" Actually Means

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

"Show, don't tell" is the most repeated advice in writing. It's also the most misunderstood. New writers think it means never stating anything directly. That's not it.

Let me show you what it actually means.

(See what I did there?)

The Basic Idea

Telling: "Sarah was angry."

Showing: "Sarah slammed the door so hard the picture frames rattled."

Telling gives information. Showing gives experience.

Readers don't want to be told how a character feels. They want to see the character act in ways that reveal those feelings.

Why Showing Works

1. Engagement

Showing makes readers do work—they have to infer meaning from details.

That work creates engagement. The reader is actively participating in the story, not just absorbing facts.

2. Trust

When you tell readers "John was terrified," you're asking them to trust you.

When you show "John's hands trembled as he reached for the doorknob," readers experience the fear themselves. They don't need to trust—they feel it.

3. Subtlety

Real emotion is complex. Rarely is someone just "angry" or "sad."

Showing allows for nuance:

"She smiled at him, but her fingers twisted the napkin in her lap."

This shows conflicting emotions in a way that "She was nervous but trying to hide it" can't.

Common Mistakes

Mistake #1: Over-Showing

Not everything needs dramatization.

Bad: "He walked to the door, turned the brass knob clockwise, pulled the heavy oak panel toward him, and stepped through the threshold into the hallway."

Better: "He left the room."

Sometimes telling is more efficient. Save showing for what matters.

Mistake #2: Explaining the Show

Bad: "Her eyes narrowed with suspicion. She didn't trust him."

Pick one. Either show (eyes narrow) or tell (she didn't trust him). Don't do both—it's redundant and insulting to your reader.

Better: "Her eyes narrowed."

Trust your reader to understand what that means.

Mistake #3: Purple Prose

Showing doesn't mean florid description.

Bad: "Tears cascaded down her porcelain cheeks like crystalline rivulets of sorrow, each droplet a testament to her ineffable grief."

Better: "Tears ran down her face."

Or even better: Show the cause, not the crying.

"She clutched the letter, reading it again. And again."

This shows grief without mentioning tears at all.

When to Tell

Yes, sometimes you should tell. Here's when:

1. Pacing

If you need to move quickly through time or compress information, tell.

"The next three weeks passed in a blur of meetings and deadlines."

Showing three weeks would kill your pacing.

2. Background Information

Readers need context. Delivering it through action would be clunky.

Awkward showing: "As he walked past the family photo on the wall—the one with his late father who had died ten years ago in a car accident—he felt sad."

Better telling: "His father had been dead for ten years."

Then show the emotion that matters now.

3. Minor Details

Save showing for what's important.

Tell: "The room was small."

Show (only if the cramped space matters): "He couldn't extend his arms without touching both walls."

4. Establishing Facts

Sometimes you just need to convey information.

"The train left at 6am."

Don't waste words showing this unless it's plot-critical.

The Real Rule

"Show, don't tell" should be:

"Show what matters. Tell the rest."

Emotional beats? Show them.

Character revelations? Show them.

Key plot moments? Show them.

Transitions? Tell.

Mundane actions? Tell.

Exposition? Tell (efficiently).

How to Show Emotions

Instead of naming the emotion, show:

1. Physical Reactions

• Fear: "His breath came in short gasps."
• Anger: "Her jaw clenched."
• Attraction: "His gaze lingered on her mouth."
• Sadness: "She stared at the ceiling, unblinking."

2. Actions

• Nervousness: "He checked his phone for the fifth time in as many minutes."
• Excitement: "She couldn't sit still. She paced. Checked the window. Paced again."
• Exhaustion: "He dropped into the chair without bothering to remove his coat."

3. Dialogue

What characters say (and don't say) reveals emotion.

Telling: "He was lying."

Showing:

"Where were you?"
"Out."
"Out where?"
He shrugged. "Just out."

The evasiveness shows he's hiding something.

4. Choices

Characters reveal themselves through what they choose.

Telling: "Maria was kind."

Showing: "Maria noticed the homeless man shivering. She gave him her scarf without hesitating."

The Iceberg Principle

Hemingway's advice: show 10%, imply 90%.

You don't need to explain everything. Give readers enough to infer the rest.

Example:

"She wore her mother's ring. It was too big."

What this implies (without stating):

• Her mother is probably dead
• She's younger/smaller than her mother was
• She values the connection enough to wear it anyway
• There's loss here

Two sentences. Layers of meaning.

Show in Dialogue

Dialogue is one of the best "showing" tools.

Telling: "James was arrogant and condescending."

Showing:

"You wouldn't understand," James said. "It's a bit complex."
"Try me."
"No offense, but I doubt you've taken graduate-level economics."

His words reveal arrogance without you ever stating it.

Show Through Setting

Setting can show character and mood.

Telling: "The house was neglected."

Showing: "Weeds choked the walkway. A shutter hung by one hinge, tapping against the siding in the wind."

Setting as metaphor:

"The flowers in the vase were dead, but no one had thrown them out."

This shows neglect, depression, or emotional stagnation without stating it.

When Writers Over-Show

New writers, terrified of "telling," over-show everything:

Over-shown:

"She lifted the ceramic mug to her lips, feeling the warmth seep through her fingers. The bitter liquid touched her tongue—coffee, dark roast, no sugar—and slid down her throat. She set the mug on the wooden table with a soft clink."

Better: "She drank her coffee."

Unless the coffee matters (poison? a ritual? symbolic?), don't belabor it.

The Balance

Great writing mixes showing and telling.

Example from published fiction:

"He was afraid. [TELL] His hands shook as he reached for the gun. [SHOW] He'd never killed anyone before. [TELL] Could he do it now? [INTERNAL THOUGHT]"

Notice the rhythm: Tell, Show, Tell, Reflect. This keeps the pace while creating emotional depth.

My Process

When writing Threads of Resilience, my first draft had too much telling:

"Amara was exhausted and scared, but she refused to give up."

Revision:

"Amara's legs trembled. She gripped the railing to steady herself, took one more breath, and climbed."

Same information. But the second version lets you experience her determination instead of being told about it.

The Trust Factor

Showing says: "I trust you to understand."

Telling says: "Let me explain."

Readers appreciate being trusted. They want to figure things out, not have everything spelled out.

Over-explained:

"He slammed his fist on the table, which showed how angry he was. He was furious because his boss had disrespected him."

Trusting the reader:

"He slammed his fist on the table. 'I'm done.'"

The reader infers the anger. You don't need to explain it.

The "Said" Debate

Related to show-don't-tell: dialogue tags.

Telling (with adverbs):

"I hate you," she said angrily.

Showing (with action):

"I hate you." She threw the glass across the room.

Or just:

"I hate you."

The words themselves show the anger. You don't need to explain.

Exercises

Exercise 1: Convert Telling to Showing

Take these "telling" sentences and rewrite them as "showing":

• "Marcus was jealous."
• "The neighborhood was dangerous."
• "She loved him."

Possible solutions:

• "Marcus watched them dance, his fists clenched at his sides."
• "Three buildings on the block had bars on the windows. A car alarm wailed in the distance."
• "She memorized the way he laughed—stored it away like a secret."

Exercise 2: Find the Balance

Take a paragraph from your work. Identify every instance of telling. Ask:

• Does this need to be shown?
• If yes, rewrite it.
• If no, leave it (or cut it).

Final Thought

"Show, don't tell" isn't a rule. It's a tool.

Use it when you want:

• Emotional impact
• Reader engagement
• Subtlety
• Immersion

Ignore it when you need:

• Pace
• Efficiency
• Clarity
• Transition

The best writers know when to show and when to tell.

And they don't agonize over it—they just write what feels right, then revise.

---